June 20, 2005

The irony of hate mail . . .

by

In a “counter-argument” to Lynne Truss‘ wildly successful tirade against poor grammar, Eats, Shoots & Leaves, Australian linguistics professor Kate Burridge has published Weeds in the Garden of Words, “a book that celebrates slang and poor punctuation.” In a story for The Independent by Genevieve Roberts, Burridge says, “Today’s weeds — non-grammatical expressions and pronunciations — are often rewarding garden species if left to grow.” For example, she says that “E-mail chat over the internet is a kind of speech written down, it has loosened the straitjacket effect to language that writing had. For example, the word ‘gonna’, as opposed to ‘going to’, is a marker of future time to replace ‘will’.” But so far Burridge is not getting the ecstatic reception Truss experienced. “When I suggested on radio that the possessive apostrophe should be dropped from the language because people get it wrong so often, you would have thought that a public flogging would not have been a severe enough punishment,” she tells Roberts. “I received hate mail, and letters from the apostrophe support group, though not all of them used the apostrophe correctly.”

Dennis Johnson is the founder of MobyLives, and the co-founder and co-publisher of Melville House.

MobyLives